top of page

Anselm: New scholasticism


Besides his three main theological works, Molologion, Proslogion, and Cur Deus Homo (Why God Became Man) , he wrote studies on semantics, truth, and freedom. In his final, unfinished work, On power and Powerlessness, Possibility and Impossibility, Necessity and Liberty, he tried to unravel the mystery of how a soul could come into existence.


Unlike ancient Greek philosophy, which was essentially the work of individuals, Scholasticism was an attempt to build philosophy as part of a "Christian society" whose purpose in turn was to transcend both individuals and nations. As the corporate product of social thought, scholastic reasoning depended on obedience to authority as espoused by the traditional forms of thought codified within the supposedly "revealed" Christian religion under the auspices of the church. As a result, philosophy was subjugated to thelolgy and rigidly controlled by the authoritarian hierarchy of the church.


On Free Will he identified the necessary conditions for the concept of free will. In On the Devil's Fall he used the idea of the fall from grace by a God-created Satan to argue that the existence of evil is compatible with the existence of an all-good God.


Anselm's facility with linguistic analysis paved the way for his most faous work, Proslogion. In it, Anselm originates the famous ontological argument for the existence of God. Later thinkers were vehemently divided over it. Those inclined toward a Platonic or Neoplatonic realism about universals in which the role of essences is emphasized over materialism - such as Descartes, Spinoza, and Hegel - each accepted some form of the ontological argument as valid and profound. Those under the influence of Aristotelian nominalism - such as the Empiricists - rejected the argument as mere verbal trickery; thus Aquinas, Hume, and Kant all dismissed it.


除了他的三大神学著作,Molologion, Proslogion,和Cur Deus Homo(为什么上帝成为人),他还写了语义学,真理和自由的研究。在他最后一部未完成的作品中,关于权力与无能、可能性与不可能性、必然性与自由,他试图揭开灵魂如何产生的奥秘。


古希腊哲学本质上是个人的工作,而经院哲学不同于古希腊哲学,它试图把哲学建设成“基督教社会”的一部分,而“基督教社会”的目的则是超越个人和国家。作为社会思想的共同产物,学术推理依赖于对权威的服从,而权威是由传统的思想形式所支持的,这些思想形式在被认为是“神昭示”的基督教中,在教会的支持下编纂而成。结果,哲学屈从于法理学,并被教会的威权统治阶层严格控制。


关于自由意志,他确定了自由意志概念的必要条件。在《魔鬼的堕落》一书中,他用上帝创造的撒旦从恩典中堕落的观点来论证邪恶的存在与全善上帝的存在是一致的。


安瑟尔姆的语言分析能力为他最出色的作品《Proslogion》铺平了道路。其中,安塞姆引发了著名的关于上帝存在的本体论论证。后来的思想家对此产生了激烈的分歧。那些倾向于柏拉图主义或新柏拉图主义的关于普遍性的现实主义的人,他们强调本质的作用而不是唯物主义,例如笛卡尔、斯宾诺莎和黑格尔,他们都接受某种形式的本体论论证,认为它是有效而深刻的。那些受亚里士多德唯名论影响的人,如经验主义者,反对这种论点,认为它仅仅是一种口头上的欺骗;因此,阿奎那、休谟和康德都摒弃了这一观点。

3 views3 comments

Recent Posts

See All

3 Comments


willer
willer
Dec 29, 2018

Write an essay stating and explaining the purpose of a religion you know and analyzing its significance.

写一篇文章,陈述和解释你所知道的宗教的目的,并分析它的意义。


https://lanfeizi.wixsite.com/english-learning/blog/the-purpose-and-significance-of-taoism

道教的目的和意义

Like

willer
willer
Dec 29, 2018

Paramount to understanding Anselm's thinking here is the distinction between an idea that exists in reality - in re - and an idea that exists only in conception - in intellectu. Anselm's argument is that if an idea is the greatest then it must exist in re, not just in intellectu, since it is greater to exist in reality than merely in the conception. That is why any supreme or perfect idea, such as Being, exists in re, why reality itself has existence in actuality not just in concept (for instance, merely in intellectu in the mind of God). This line of argument - based on Plato's realistic metaphysics and buttressed by Augustine's Neoplatonic reinterpretation of Christian dogma - was…


Like

willer
willer
Dec 29, 2018

Anselm quotes from Psalms "The fool has said in his heart, There is no God" in an attempt to equate the denial of God with a self-contradiction, something only a fool would do. According to Anselm God's existence can be derived from the very meaning of "God", which he defines as the greatest conceivable being greater than which "cannot be conceived". He then claims that since existence is greater than nonexistence, to say that "God does not exist" is tantamount to saying something like, "A being that cannot be conceived as anything other than existing does not exist" or "A being that exists necessarily does not exist" which according to Anselm is self-contradictory.


安瑟尔姆引用诗篇中的“愚人心里说,没有上帝”,试图把否认上帝等同于自相矛盾,这是只有愚人才能做到的。根据安瑟伦的观点,上帝的存在可以从“上帝”的意义中得到,他把“上帝”定义为最大的可想象的存在,而不是“不能被构想”的存在。他接着声称,既然存在大于不存在,那么说“上帝不存在”就等于说,“一个不能被构想为除存在之外的任何事物的存在不存在”或“一个必然存在的存在不存在”,根据安瑟姆的说法,这是自相矛盾的。

Like
bottom of page